There are lots of methods to choose a financial institution inventory. Right here’s what labored (and what didn’t)

Canadian financial institution shares struggled in 2022, as tumbling share costs underperformed the S&P/TSX Composite Index. However the sector’s robust long-term efficiency and dependable dividends are compelling causes for buyers to present banks one other look – so the place ought to they search for alternatives?

Maybe this scorecard will help. By inspecting financial institution inventory efficiency utilizing a few of the extra common approaches, buyers can see what went proper and what went fallacious in 2022, and get a glimpse of potential concepts for 2023.

Ignore the inventory, purchase the dividend: Since financial institution dividends are rock-solid, shopping for the financial institution inventory with the best dividend yield has some enchantment. A excessive yield means that the inventory could also be undervalued. It additionally signifies that the inventory will ship additional cash, including to its whole return.

Did this strategy ship outcomes this yr? No.

The inventory with the best yield on the finish of 2021 was Financial institution of Nova Scotia BNS-T, at 4.5 per cent, adopted carefully by Canadian Imperial Financial institution of Commerce CM-T, at 4.4 per cent. However each shares delivered the worst returns among the many Huge Six banks, falling 26 per cent every in 2022, as of early Friday.

Utilizing dividend yield as a stock-picking method for 2023 delivers the identical two candidates, however with even larger yields. Scotiabank now yields 6.3 per cent whereas CIBC yields 6.2 per cent. For buyers who like earnings, these yields could also be exhausting to withstand.

The worst inventory is the most effective inventory: Canadian banks have an uncanny capacity to bounce again from a shedding streak – a development often known as reverting to the imply – so shopping for the earlier yr’s worst performer can ship enticing outcomes.

Did this strategy work in 2022? Completely.

Royal Financial institution of Canada RY-T was the sector’s laggard in 2021, when the share value trailed all of its friends and lagged the common return for the Huge Six banks by about six proportion factors. An investor who picked RBC for 2022, based mostly on this laggard standing, suffered a modest lack of 5.2 per cent this yr (not one of the returns used on this story embrace dividends). Although that tied Nationwide Financial institution of Canada’s decline, it outperformed the Huge Six common return by a considerable 8.8 proportion factors.

Utilizing this method to choose a winner for 2023 means sidling as much as Scotiabank or CIBC and embracing their 26-per-cent declines this yr as a motive to be enthusiastic concerning the shares.

The bottom valuation shines brightest: Analysts use plenty of methods to take a look at financial institution inventory valuations, however one of many easiest compares the present share value to estimated earnings.

If low cost is nice, then the most effective choose for 2022 was CIBC, with a sector-trailing price-to-earnings ratio of 9.8 initially of the yr. That in contrast with a peer common P/E of about 10.5, in accordance with Bloomberg knowledge.

The issue: This yr, low cost received cheaper. CIBC’s P/E ratio fell to about eight in December after the financial institution’s share value slumped.

For buyers who wish to take one other crack at selecting a financial institution inventory utilizing this strategy to valuation, Scotiabank is on observe to finish the yr with the sector’s lowest P/E, at 7.8, edging out CIBC as the cut price financial institution for 2023.

Simply purchase all of them: Anybody who doesn’t belief their stock-picking expertise might favor the diversification of a whole basket of Canadian financial institution shares utilizing an exchange-traded fund. You gained’t get particular person winners this fashion, however you gained’t be saddled with laggards both.

A few of the main ETFs take totally different approaches, although.

The RBC Canadian Financial institution Yield Index ETF (RBNK) holds the Huge Six financial institution shares weighted in accordance with their dividend yields. The 2 highest-yielding shares every account for 1 / 4 of the fund; the 2 lowest-yielding shares every account for a twelfth of the fund. The ETF fell 16.2 per cent in 2022.

The BMO Equal Weight Banks Index ETF (ZEB) holds an equal weighting of all six big-bank shares, and is steadily rebalanced. The fund fell 13.5 per cent in 2022.

The Hamilton Enhanced Canadian Financial institution ETF (HCAL) places a heavier weighting on shares which were underperforming, utilizing a revert-to-the-mean technique. It additionally offers 25-per-cent leverage, boosting an investor’s publicity to the sector and enhancing dividends. With financial institution shares down this yr, although, the unit value has slumped 22.5 per cent.

Clearly, equal weighting labored greatest for ETFs throughout the market turbulence of 2022 – although financial institution buyers had nothing to brag about with any ETF or stock-picking strategy this yr, given the hunch.

The great factor about financial institution shares? Over the long run, all of them ship good returns, even if you select fallacious.

Full disclosure: The writer owns items of ZEB.

Be good along with your cash. Get the most recent investing insights delivered proper to your inbox 3 times per week, with the Globe Investor e-newsletter. Join right now.