investor clinicWith break up shares, that fats dividend is not any free lunch
I’m hoping you might touch upon Dividend 15 Break up Corp. Its class A shares yield greater than 15 per cent, however the corporations it invests in solely yield about 5 per cent, on common. This appears too good to be true. What am I lacking?
When a yield soars nicely into the double digits, there’s at all times a catch. Let’s raise the curtain and see how that supersized yield is generated.
Like different split-share firms – of which there are a few dozen in Canada – Dividend 15 Break up points two courses of shares to traders: most well-liked shares DFN-PR-A and sophistication A shares DFN-T, also called capital shares.
Break up preferreds are the extra conservative of the 2. Typically, the preferreds are first in line for the dividends – as much as a sure degree – spun off by shares within the underlying portfolio, which on this case is a basket of Canadian banks, pipelines, telecoms, utilities and different dividend-paying corporations. Upon windup, the preferreds additionally get first declare on the capital within the portfolio, as much as their situation worth. (Dividend 15 Break up has a termination date of Dec. 1, 2024, however split-share firms sometimes lengthen the date in five-year increments.)
Reflecting these security options, break up preferreds present regular earnings however little upside potential. Though their bond-like traits make them delicate to rising rates of interest, volatility is usually modest. Dividend 15 Break up’s most well-liked shares at present yield about 5.9 per cent.
The category A shares – also called capital shares – are a lot much less predictable. Primarily, they’re entitled to the entire worth within the portfolio over and above the fastened quantity allotted to the preferreds. Due to this leveraged construction, if the underlying shares rise, the category A shares usually expertise a good bigger acquire. However the reverse can be true: If the underlying shares fall, the category A shares could have a bigger decline.
What’s extra, the category A shares are required to droop dividend funds if the web asset worth of the split-share company falls beneath a sure threshold, which in Dividend 15 Break up’s case is $15 per unit. (A unit consists of 1 most well-liked share and one capital share.) That’s exactly what occurred in 2020 when the pandemic-induced market selloff prompted Dividend 15 Break up to droop dividends on its class A shares in April, Might, June and November of that yr. The break up preferreds, however, didn’t miss a single fee.
So the place does the money come from to pay the outsized dividends on the category A shares?
With break up capital shares normally, there are sometimes three sources of funds: any extra dividend earnings from the underlying portfolio (after the preferreds have obtained their fastened minimize); premium earnings from writing covered-call choices on shares; and capital features within the portfolio.
It’s necessary to know, nevertheless, that the fats yield on the category A shares shouldn’t be a free lunch. With a lot money going out the door each month, DFN’s share worth has been grinding decrease for years. Within the 5 years ended Dec. 31, for instance, DFN dropped about 30 per cent, at the same time as Canada’s benchmark index rose nearly 20 per cent. So, whereas traders have been gathering a juicy dividend, they’ve successfully been subsidizing the payout with an erosion of their very own capital.
Whenever you mix DFN’s excessive yield with its falling inventory worth, its return abruptly appears to be like very extraordinary. For the 5 years by way of Dec. 31, DFN’s annualized complete return was 6.49 per cent, in response to the compound returns calculator at canadastockchannel.com. (Complete returns assume all dividends had been reinvested in extra shares.) A low-cost exchange-traded fund that tracks the S&P/TSX Composite Index would have produced a just about an identical consequence. Granted, an index ETF received’t generate the identical degree of money circulate, however traders can obtain the same consequence by periodically promoting a portion of their securities. (Tip: Use a dealer that gives commission-free ETF trades.)
What’s extra, Dividend 15 Break up’s internet asset worth per unit has additionally been trending decrease. For the 5 years by way of 2016, the NAV averaged about $19.60. Within the following 5 years, it averaged $17.50. (These figures are primarily based on the NAV per unit at Nov. 30 every year, as offered in Dividend 15 Break up’s annual administration report of fund efficiency.) As of the newest replace, on Dec. 30, 2022, the NAV per unit had dropped to $15.45 – uncomfortably near the $15 threshold at which dividends on the category A shares are suspended − though the NAV has doubtless risen since then together with the broader market.
So, earlier than you bounce right into a split-share funding corresponding to DFN, contemplate the large image: Sure, you’ll be getting a big dividend, however you’ll additionally doubtless face elevated volatility, potential long-term erosion of the share worth and the danger that dividends will dry up if issues get ugly on the market.
E-mail your inquiries to [email protected]. I’m not capable of reply personally to e-mails however I select sure inquiries to reply in my column.
Be good along with your cash. Get the newest investing insights delivered proper to your inbox 3 times every week, with the Globe Investor publication. Join as we speak.